Caste Census in India: The Political Debate

 Caste Census in India: The Political Debate

The issue of conducting a caste census in India has sparked intense political debates, primarily revolving around the need for social justice, electoral advantages, and administrative concerns. The discourse is shaped by historical, social, and economic factors, with different political parties taking contrasting positions based on their ideological leanings and voter base.

1. What is a Caste Census?

A caste census refers to the enumeration of various castes in the country, particularly Other Backward Classes (OBCs), Scheduled Castes (SCs), and Scheduled Tribes (STs). While the decennial Census records SC and ST populations, it does not officially enumerate OBCs since the 1931 Census, which was the last caste-based enumeration in India.

Why is a caste census being demanded?

  • To ascertain the exact population of OBCs and EBCs (Extremely Backward Classes) for better policy formulation.
  • To revise reservation policies based on accurate data rather than outdated estimates.
  • To address claims that OBCs are underrepresented in education, jobs, and politics.

2. Political Debate: Proponents vs Opponents

A. Supporters of the Caste Census

Several regional and national parties strongly advocate for a caste census, particularly those representing OBCs and Dalits.

1. Regional Parties and Mandal Politics

  • Bihar & Uttar Pradesh: The demand is strongest in states with a history of Mandal politics (affirmative action for OBCs). Bihar, under CM Nitish Kumar (JD(U)) and RJD, conducted its own caste survey in 2023, setting a precedent.
  • Samajwadi Party (SP) and Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD): These parties argue that without a caste census, OBCs are being denied their rightful share in government benefits and reservation.

2. Congress’ Stand

  • The Congress Party has shifted its stance and now supports a caste census, particularly after Rahul Gandhi’s "Jitni Abadi, Utna Haq" (Rights as per Population) slogan.
  • It claims that the Modi government is avoiding the caste census to protect upper-caste interests.

3. Dalit and Social Justice Movements

  • Social justice groups, Ambedkarite scholars, and activists argue that caste census is necessary to correct historical injustices.
  • They believe that existing reservations are based on outdated data, and a census will help redistribute resources equitably.

B. Opponents of the Caste Census

The BJP-led central government and some other groups have expressed reservations about a caste census.

1. BJP’s Position

  • The BJP government has not openly supported a caste census, arguing that it could lead to social divisions.
  • Instead, it promotes economic criteria (EWS - Economically Weaker Sections) over caste-based reservations.
  • BJP leaders fear that a caste census may encourage sub-categorization within OBCs, weakening their consolidated Hindu voter base.

2. Fear of Social Fragmentation

  • Some critics argue that caste enumeration will reinforce caste identities, leading to deeper divisions rather than national unity.
  • They worry that caste-based data may be politically exploited for vote-bank politics rather than genuine social development.

3. Bureaucratic and Administrative Challenges

  • Officials cite logistical difficulties in conducting a caste census for 1.4 billion people.
  • Some fear that it may lead to endless demands for sub-categorization and new reservations, complicating governance.

3. Key Developments & Supreme Court View

  • Bihar Caste Survey (2023): It revealed OBCs and EBCs form over 63% of Bihar’s population, sparking fresh debates at the national level.
  • Karnataka & Tamil Nadu: Regional governments have started collecting caste data through socio-economic surveys.
  • Supreme Court: The judiciary has ruled that states can collect socio-economic caste data but has not mandated a national caste census.

4. Impact on 2024 Elections

The caste census has become a major electoral issue, with the opposition trying to corner the BJP by demanding caste-based population data. The BJP, while cautious, has emphasized economic welfare schemes for backward classes without committing to a formal caste census.

Conclusion

The caste census debate is a battle between social justice advocates and those who fear social fragmentation. While proponents argue that it will ensure equitable representation and development, opponents worry about political exploitation and governance challenges. As India moves towards the 2024 general elections, this issue is likely to play a crucial role in shaping political narratives and voter sentiments.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Chenchulu of Nallamala

 నీడ కోల్పోతున్న నల్లమల చెంచులు ABN , Publish Date - Feb 25 , 2025 | 03:13 AM ప్రపంచం మొత్తంమీద మన దేశంలో అడవి తెగల జనాభా అధికం. అందుకే భారతదేశం అడవిబిడ్డల మానవశాస్త్ర పరిశోధనశాల. 2011 జనాభా లెక్కల ప్రకారం... నీడ కోల్పోతున్న నల్లమల చెంచులు ప్రపంచం మొత్తంమీద మన దేశంలో అడవి తెగల జనాభా అధికం. అందుకే భారతదేశం అడవిబిడ్డల మానవశాస్త్ర పరిశోధనశాల. 2011 జనాభా లెక్కల ప్రకారం ఉమ్మడి ఆంధ్రప్రదేశ్‌లో షెడ్యూల్డు తెగలు 35. ఇందులో చెంచులు అతి వెనుకబడ్డ గుంపులో ఉన్నారు. ప్రత్యేకంగా నల్లమల అడవుల్లో చెంచుల జనాభా 64,227. వీరు షెడ్యూల్డ్‌ తెగల జాబితాలో మూడవ స్థానంలో ఉన్నారు. ఉమ్మడి ఆంధ్రప్రదేశ్‌లో షెడ్యూల్డ్‌ తెగల జనాభా 59,18,000 కాగా చెంచులు 5.6 శాతం ఉన్నారు. అడవి లోపలి భాగాన కొండ వరసలలో చెంచు గుడిసెలు గుంపులుగా పెంట లేక గ్రామంగా ఉంటాయి. వీరి ముఖ్యమైన వృత్తి వేట. వేటాడిన జంతుజాలంతో పాటు అడవి చెట్ల నుండి లభించే వివిధ తినుబండారాలు వారి ఆహారం. కొంతమంది నల్లమల అడవులలో వ్యవసాయాన్ని కూడా వృత్తిగా అనుసరిస్తున్నారు. వీరికి విద్య, అవగాహన లేవు. వీరిని ఆదిమ గిరిజన సమూహాలు అంటారు. ఇంత వెనుకబడ్డ జీవనాన్ని సాగిస్తు...
Read more

Gujarati financial influence on the Indian economy

 Gujarati financial influence on the Indian economy, particularly through major business houses, is a significant topic. Over the years, prominent Gujarati industrialists and entrepreneurs have played a dominant role in shaping India's economic landscape. Here are ten major examples that establish how Gujarati finance controls a large portion of the Indian economy, particularly in infrastructure, contracts, and business monopolies. 1. Adani Group – Infrastructure & Energy Monopoly The Adani Group, led by Gautam Adani, has become India's largest infrastructure player. It dominates ports (Adani Ports), airports (Adani Airports), power (Adani Power & Adani Green Energy), and even the cement sector (Ambuja & ACC). Adani’s projects are spread across highways, expressways, and metro contracts, making him a key player in India's development agenda. 2. Reliance Industries – Petroleum, Telecom & Retail Supremacy Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Industries, headquartered in G...
Read more

Row over CPI(M) not calling Modi govt ‘fascist’; Vijayan eyeing ‘BJP vote’: Cong

 Row over CPI(M) not calling Modi govt ‘fascist’; Vijayan eyeing ‘BJP vote’: Cong           Deviating from other Left outfits, CPI(M) note on draft political resolution for 24th Party Congress says the party does not consider Modi govt “fascist or neo-fascist” despite its “neo-fascist characteristics" Written by Shaju Philip Thiruvananthapuram | Updated: February 25, 2025 07:48 IST Newsguard A K Balan clarifies CPI(M)'s stance on Modi government, saying it is not considered fascist or neo-fascist.  The CPI(M) leadership’s move to issue a clarification that the party does not consider the Narendra Modi-led government “fascist or neo-fascist” has kicked up a row in Kerala, with the principal Opposition Congress alleging that the CPI(M)’s stance was part of its bid to remain “loyal” to the Sangh Parivar. The CPI(M) recently released its draft political resolution for the 24th Party Congress – slated to be held in Madurai from April 2 to 6, 2025 – whi...
Read more